At first glance, a praying mantis perched motionless on a flower looks harmless. Yet behind those folded forelimbs lies a stealthy predator. Mantises regularly feast on pollinators, including honey bees. While they help control pests, mantises may also threaten bee populations. This raises an important question – are praying mantises friends or foes to honey bees?
The Hunting Habits of Mantises
Praying mantises are carnivorous insects with a huge appetite for live prey. They eat all types of insects but seem especially fond of bees, wasps, butterflies, and moths. Mantises snatch their victims with lightning-quick raptorial forelegs armed with rows of sharp spines. They grasp prey tightly and consume it alive.
Mantises lie in ambush, camouflaged amidst vegetation. Their bugged-out eyes have excellent vision to detect the slightest movement. Mantises strike targets up to 6 inches away in about 1/20th of a second. Honey bees bumbling between flowers make easy marks for mantises.
Documented Mantises vs. Bees
There are several accounts of mantises preying on honey bees. A beekeeper captured photos of a European mantis consuming one of his bees. The series of images shows the mantis clutched onto the struggling bee slowly devouring it headfirst.
Other beekeepers have spotted mantises perched on hives waiting to pounce on bees One keeper even observed the same mantis repeatedly returning to her hives after being relocated This mantis seemed intent on dining on the hive’s inhabitants.
Quantifying the Threat to Bees
How often do mantises actually eat bees, and could this predation impact bee populations? The scarcity of data makes the threat uncertain. However, a few studies provide clues.
Research in New Jersey orchards found mantises eat primarily beneficial insects. Bees and wasps comprised over 25% of their diet. Another study identified mantises as significant predators of bees in squash fields, consuming 11-37% of released bees.
Though limited, these studies suggest mantises may significantly affect bees in certain agricultural settings. More research is needed to clarify the magnitude of mantises’ impact across different environments.
Benefits of Mantises for Pest Control
Despite eating pollinators, mantises help by devouring pest insects. Their appetite for caterpillars, beetles, leafhoppers, and other orchard pests makes them valuable for biological control.
For example, experiments adding mantises to apple trees reduced caterpillar damage more effectively than pesticide. Mantises may also protect bees by eating hive pests like wax moths and small hive beetles. Eliminating these threats outweighs the occasional loss of a bee.
Coexistence Strategies for Bees & Mantises
Whilemantises eat bees, both insects provide important ecosystem services. With thoughtful management, we can promote coexistence of mantises and bees. Here are some tips:
-
Monitor mantis population density. Lower densities minimize bee losses while retaining pest control benefits.
-
Provide alternate prey sources like aphids so mantises bother bees less.
-
Add artificial shelters for bees to hide from mantises near nests and hives.
-
Remove egg cases to limit mantis numbers, but avoid over-suppressing them.
-
Plant flowers preferred by bees over mantises to segregate the insects.
-
Relocate excess mantises from sensitive areas to preserve more bees.
A Complex Relationship
The relationship between praying mantises and bees proves complex. Mantises undoubtedly feast on honey bees yet also eliminate bee predators. Their predatory nature makes mantises a potential concern for beekeepers and farmers.
However, viewing mantises only as threats overlooks their value in biological control. With thoughtful management, we can achieve a balance allowing both mantises and bees to thrive. A nuanced understanding of mantis ecology will enable the sustainable integration of these insects in agricultural and natural ecosystems.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do praying mantises eat honey bees?
Mantises eat bees for the nutrition, calories, and protein they provide. Bees are plentiful and easy for mantises to catch, making them a convenient food source.
How often do praying mantises prey on bees?
Studies show mantises may consume a significant portion of bees in agricultural fields during certain times of year. But more data is needed to determine the frequency in natural settings.
Do praying mantises eat bumblebees too?
Yes, mantises will eat any type of bee they can successfully capture and subdue. Bumblebees are less frequent prey but can fall victim to mantises occasionally.
Should I kill praying mantises near my beehives?
Killing all mantises could do more harm than good by eliminating their pest control benefits. It’s better to monitor mantis numbers and remove excess individuals, while preserving some for biological control.
What times of year are bees most vulnerable to mantis predation?
Bees face the highest risk during spring and summer when mantis numbers peak. Mantises may pick off emerging bees in spring or target foraging bees in summer.
How can I reduce praying mantis impacts on my bee colonies?
Strategies like monitoring mantis density, providing bees shelter, and planting bee-preferred flowers can help minimize bee losses to mantises near hives.
What preys on praying mantises?
Birds, frogs, spiders, insects like assassin bugs and ants, and even other mantis species may eat mantises. However, mantises have few natural predators as adults due to their camouflage and speed.
Are any praying mantis species harmful to bees?
There is little evidence of varying impacts on bees among mantis species. Most species exhibit similar predatory behaviors and eat bees opportunistically. Overall mantis densities matter more than species.
Can praying mantises be safely relocated?
Yes, mantises can be humanely caught and released away from sensitive areas. But avoid moving them too far as they are territorial and may fail to thrive if displaced far from their home range.
